2cdebf5ac3
Umbratools_2.md 5.0 replaces shared-tables-plus-RLS with one schema per
organization, because RLS was measured to be unenforceable twice: the
application connects as the table owner so the policies did not apply to it
(gate G2), and one app function was PUBLIC-executable until it was fixed by
hand against one database (defect B4). A model whose correctness depends on a
grant somebody remembers to make is not a boundary.
The classification comes before the SQL because the SQL's blast radius depends
on it, and the obvious reading of "move the tenant tables" is wrong for eight of
the tables carrying an organization_id. Four move: projects, project_authors,
project_publishers, invitations. The other twenty-six stay, each for a reason
read out of the actual columns and foreign keys rather than the table names.
Two findings the plan did not price, both recorded in the classification:
- user_roles cannot move. It is the index that resolves a session to an
organization, so putting it in a tenant schema means finding the tenant by
searching every tenant schema, on the login path. It also holds
platform-scope rows, which have no organization to belong to. So one table
stays shared, and 5.0's "no table is shared between organizations" is not
fully achievable while the session-to-tenant resolution is a table.
- moving projects forces dropping three foreign keys that point at it from
artifacts, jobs and user_roles, because a foreign key cannot name a table
whose schema depends on the row. That is the one place the decision costs a
database-enforced guarantee, and it is written down rather than papered over
with a trigger that would have to rediscover which tenant is meant.
The migration names each tenant schema from the organization id rather than
storing it, so a name cannot disagree with the rows and the rollback can rebuild
the organization_id column from the schema. It is idempotent - verified by
applying it twice - and the rollback is a file that runs rather than a comment
block, because a rollback for a data migration that only exists as a comment is a
rollback nobody runs. Both were applied to the scratch database, rolled back, and
applied again.
UmbraTrans local bootstrap workspace
This workspace contains the unprivileged agent-comm server requested by the Oldbox handoff. It does not contain the UmbraTrans application source: no application bundle was present locally. A staged archive, if present, is left untouched.
Layout
agent_comm/— Python 3.11+ standard-library, stdio-only MCP server.agent_comm/tests/— dependency-free unit tests.umbratrans_web/— phase-1 account/user-management backend slice (FastAPI, Argon2id, sessions, admin routes, in-memory and local JSON development repositories). It does not connect to PostgreSQL; seeumbratrans_web/README.md.umbratrans_web/migrations/— proposed, unapplied phase-1 identity SQL and its rollback.opencode.json— non-secret OpenCode registration for the confirmed NAS2 mailbox.agent-comm.local.example.json— non-secret local fallback registration..env.example— non-secret environment template.DATA-SEPARATION.md— development/production boundary.
Confirmed NAS2 mailbox
The oldbox desktop account mounted NAS2 netbackup through its user GVfs session and confirmed the UmbraTrans directory readable, searchable, and writable. The server requires the explicit NAS deployment mode, the enclosing GVfs mount, and an affirmative mount confirmation:
/run/user/1002/gvfs/smb-share:server=nas2.local,share=netbackup/UmbraTrans/agent-mailbox
Run read-only health checks:
cd /home/umbra/src/UmbraTrans
AGENT_COMM_MODE=nas \
AGENT_COMM_NAS_MOUNT=/run/user/1002/gvfs \
AGENT_COMM_NAS_CONFIRMED=1 \
AGENT_COMM_ROOT='/run/user/1002/gvfs/smb-share:server=nas2.local,share=netbackup/UmbraTrans/agent-mailbox' \
/home/umbra/.local/bin/uv run python -m agent_comm --check
If the user GVfs session is absent, do not guess another path or broaden share permissions. Use the private local fallback documented in agent-comm.local.example.json, or have a privileged operator restore the confirmed user mount.
The server speaks newline-delimited MCP JSON-RPC over stdin/stdout. It opens no network socket and never executes queued instructions.
OpenCode registration
opencode.json contains the exact NAS configuration and paths only. It must never contain passwords, tokens, private keys, or other secrets. A Mac-side reader still needs separate configuration and verification before an outbox message can be considered received.
Development workflow
The project uses uv and a workspace-local virtual environment:
cd /home/umbra/src/UmbraTrans
/home/umbra/.local/bin/uv sync --python /usr/bin/python3
/home/umbra/.local/bin/uv run python -m unittest discover -s agent_comm/tests -v
/home/umbra/.local/bin/uv run ruff check .
/home/umbra/.local/bin/uv run ruff format --check .
/home/umbra/.local/bin/uv run python -m compileall -q agent_comm
make check
The tests cover schema and size validation, atomic no-overwrite writes, restrictive modes, path traversal, symlink refusal, secret-pattern redaction, inbox processing, and read-only initialization.
The account-management slice has its own targets:
cd /home/umbra/src/UmbraTrans
/home/umbra/.local/bin/uv run pytest umbratrans_web/tests
make web-check
Its tests use the in-memory repository and generated per-run passwords; they never read a production configuration, never connect to a database, and contain no credential material.
Backups
scripts/umbratrans_backup.sh is installed root-owned as /usr/local/sbin/umbratrans-backup and scheduled by the enabled umbratrans-backup.timer. It writes only to the confirmed NAS2 netbackup/UmbraTrans/backups tree:
- PostgreSQL:
pg_dumpcustom-format logical dump, never a live data-directory copy. - Configuration: PostgreSQL configuration files only.
- Workspace: source/configuration archive excluding
.venv, Git internals, runtime data, local mailboxes, and secret-bearing files.
Each file is staged outside the share, published with an atomic rename as umbra, checksummed, and verified after publication. Retention is 30 days for PostgreSQL/configuration/manifests and 14 days for workspace archives; stale temporary files older than one hour are removed. The timer fails closed if the user GVfs mount is absent and does not mount or broaden the NAS share.
The current first-run backup set is present under:
/run/user/1002/gvfs/smb-share:server=nas2.local,share=netbackup/UmbraTrans/backups
Check timer status with systemctl status umbratrans-backup.timer and the last run with journalctl -u umbratrans-backup.service.